Who had the best C5? Why YouTube is a blessing and a curse for singers

Recently, I sat watching “Who Sang It Best C5 Showdown” on YouTube. Céline, Whitney, Mariah and more belting out C5s for 15 minutes, trying to figure out who had the best C5 (C above middle C on the piano). I was living for every minute of it.

I love YouTube; it is a treasure trove for a singing teacher. I mean, in general, it’s fantastic for cooking, DIY, knitting or anything else you love to do.

It’s a place to access millions of singers around the world in different genres and languages, which is hugely beneficial for your ear training. I’ve often found things on YouTube that I would never hear in my studio, and it makes me a more well-rounded singing teacher.

Not only that, but as a teaching resource, there are so many backing tracks in so many keys. Yes, some sound very bad and are unusable, but even the rough ones can be useful when you find a random musical theatre piano video that really requires 5 hands on the piano in a lower key.

I can honestly get lost for hours in videos and usually end up listening to compilation videos. They have all the usual suspects in them, and I love most of these singers anyway, but hearing each of them back-to-back is amazing training. Hearing the differences in vowels, textures, tongue position, tone, thick or thin sounds and breathy or belty really helps not only my ear as a teacher, but as a singer as well.

As singers, we often learn by imitating what we hear from others. There were sounds in my voice I couldn’t work out how to make, because I had nothing to compare them to. Watching videos of other singers gave me that reference.

In so many songs, I just didn’t know how to sing in the A4 to C5 range (the high notes at the top of a lot of pop and rock songs for men). It would drive me mad trying to get my voice to stop cracking or straining.

I used to listen to singers doing these songs, envious of their abilities. Then one day it clicked: if I studied what they were doing, maybe I could figure it out. Whilst it didn’t take me from zero to hero, it definitely helped get me some of the way there.

My Mariah Carey whistle notes will not come, no matter how much I try to mimic her, but copying other singers can be a great starting point. Especially if you feel like you can’t “place” a certain part of your voice.

Learning to play piano in a way is easier than learning to sing, especially if I make a mistake. I can look at the keys, check where my fingers were, what I was doing with the pedals, and figure out what went wrong, but when you can’t see your instrument, it’s much harder to understand what’s going on.

Over the years, as a singer and singing teacher, I’ve found that having a reliable mentor and teacher to work on my voice and ask questions is helpful and gets me results much faster than trying to do it on my own. Equally, doing my own research, listening, analysing and playing around whilst trying to mimic is a big part of the picture until I come across something that doesn’t make sense or is just plain nonsense. That’s when having a mentor is worth its weight in gold.

However, YouTube is also a curse for exactly the same reasons. For all the good stuff, there is just as much, if not more, cr*p on there. Conflicting opinions, wrong information and singers doing things that are not healthy, with people praising them and copying them, can all be pretty dangerous. My own experience and background, along with having other experienced teachers to ask, act as a filter for me, so I can take things with a pinch of salt when necessary.

I also recently watched a live coaching session with a singer who was straining. The coach spent 20 minutes fiddling with things that made no difference, and the singer was no better off at the end.

Watching it, I felt he needed more awareness of the vowels he was singing, instead of yelling them, and a few exercises to help him sing higher without the strain. If the coach had done that, the singer would have been in a better place and felt less frustrated.

What worries me is a singer watching at home, trying the same advice, still straining and wondering what they’re doing wrong.

I still love YouTube. It’s given me more singers than I’ll ever hear in my studio, and it’s making me a better teacher and singer. I’ve learned to watch it with my filter on now, separating the wheat from the chaff, and I’ll happily lose another 15 minutes to a C5 showdown any day.

Do you watch singers on YouTube for entertainment, training or both? Hit reply. I’d love to hear from you.